How Liberalism Is Leading to the Downfall of America
A conservative argument about what happens when progressive policy puts ideology ahead of evidence in health care, immigration, public safety, and education.

Liberalism’s core problem is not compassion. It is the refusal to acknowledge reality when that reality offends someone. When feelings and group identity are elevated above biological facts, criminal statistics, cultural compatibility, and measurable outcomes, the result is predictable: institutions weaken, public safety erodes, and the shared culture that holds a nation together fractures. The following are concrete ways this is playing out.
Affirming Mental Illness as Identity, Especially for Children
Biological sex is binary and immutable in humans. Men are not women. This is not a belief; it is a fact of reproductive biology. Yet progressive institutions treat gender dysphoria as an identity that must be affirmed rather than a mental health condition that should be treated carefully. The result has been a sharp rise in youth identifying as transgender, medicalization of minors, and suppression of dissent.
The 2024 Cass Review in the United Kingdom examined the evidence base for puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones in minors and found it “remarkably weak.” There was insufficient evidence that these interventions improve mental health or resolve dysphoria, and concerns about impacts on bone density, fertility, cognitive development, and the possibility that blockers alter the trajectory of identity formation. The NHS subsequently banned routine use of puberty blockers for gender dysphoria in under-18s, with an indefinite restriction following expert advice. Multiple European countries (Sweden, Finland, Norway) had already moved toward more cautious, therapy-first approaches after similar evidence reviews.
In the United States, progressive medical organizations and school policies have continued the affirmation model. Social transition, preferred pronouns, and access to medical interventions have been pushed on children, sometimes with parental involvement minimized or schools withholding information from parents. Rapid-onset gender dysphoria clusters, high rates of co-occurring autism and mental health conditions, and rising detransition reports have been downplayed. The fear of being labeled bigoted has overridden caution around irreversible interventions on minors. This is not compassion. It is ideological capture that risks harming the very children it claims to protect.
Open Borders Without Assimilation Requirements
Record illegal immigration under progressive administrations has strained every system. CBP data and House Homeland Security reports documented more than 10.8 million encounters nationwide since FY2021 and roughly 2 million known gotaways. Hundreds of individuals on the terrorist watchlist were encountered at the southwest border; dozens were released into the interior. Special interest aliens from countries of concern rose sharply. This is not abstract. It is a deliberate policy choice that prioritizes volume and process over vetting and control.
Assimilation is not optional for long-term cohesion. Large majorities of Muslims in many origin countries support sharia as official or guiding law (Pew Research Center surveys across dozens of countries). In Europe, polling has shown substantial minorities of Muslim immigrants favoring elements of sharia over host-country law. French Ifop data indicated significant support among French Muslims for applying Muslim law, higher among the young. Practices incompatible with Western constitutional order—honor-based violence, unequal treatment of women under religious law, child marriage traditions in some communities, and public prayer that shuts down infrastructure—have appeared in Western cities. Sweden’s police identify “vulnerable areas” with parallel social structures, high criminal influence, and difficulty carrying out basic policing; these areas have heavy immigrant populations. Gang violence tied to imported clan and migration-related networks has forced policy reversals even in historically open Nordic countries.
Liberals treat demands for accommodation as tolerance and resistance as bigotry. The Constitution is not a buffet. Sharia-derived practices that permit wife-beating as discipline, honor killings, or marriage of young girls are incompatible with American law and equal protection. Demanding that host societies rearrange traffic, public spaces, or legal standards around these practices is not integration. It is conquest by demographic and political pressure.
Sanctuary Policies and Soft-on-Crime Governance
Sanctuary jurisdictions systematically decline ICE detainers. California agencies alone have ignored thousands; Los Angeles Police Department compliance has been near zero in some reporting periods. House Judiciary and CIS analyses document releases of individuals with homicide, sexual assault, and other serious convictions or charges. When local authorities refuse to hold criminal aliens for federal pickup, those individuals re-enter communities. Specific cases in Illinois and California show reoffending after ignored detainers, including violent crimes. Progressive district attorneys in major cities have declined prosecutions, eliminated cash bail for many offenses, and prioritized “equity” over incapacitation of repeat offenders. The 2020–2021 homicide spike was the largest single-year increase in modern records; cities that reduced proactive policing or cut budgets saw some of the steepest rises. Later declines occurred where policies were reversed or enforcement increased—not where the original progressive approach was doubled down.
The Education System’s Decline into Equity Theater
NAEP (“Nation’s Report Card”) results show multi-year declines in reading and math that began before the pandemic and continued after. Twelfth-grade reading and math scores hit multi-decade lows. Large shares of students score below basic proficiency. The lowest-performing students have fallen furthest. Progressive education priorities—participation over mastery, elimination of tracking or rigorous standards in the name of equity, reduced discipline for “disparate impact,” and curriculum focused on identity rather than knowledge—have correlated with these results. Grade inflation and social promotion keep students moving while actual skills stagnate. When the goal is equal outcomes rather than equal opportunity and high standards, the system produces neither competence nor social mobility. Declining scores predate COVID and persist despite massive spending increases.
Additional Patterns
Progressive campus culture has produced widespread free-speech suppression through DEI bureaucracies, bias response teams, and student pressure. FIRE data has tracked hundreds of cases of students and faculty punished for protected speech. The same institutions that enforce orthodoxy on race and gender often tolerate or encourage disruption when the politics align with the left. Homelessness policies that prioritize “Housing First” without addressing addiction, mental illness, or public order have left West Coast cities with visible encampments, public drug use, and crime, while cities that combine housing with enforcement and treatment have shown better results. Energy and climate policies that reject nuclear and reliable baseload power in favor of intermittent sources have raised costs and reduced reliability without proportional global emissions reductions. Affirmative action and equity hiring that de-emphasize merit have been struck down by the Supreme Court in higher education precisely because they conflict with equal protection; the same logic applies elsewhere.
These are not isolated mistakes. They share a common root: the progressive refusal to rank reality higher than the fear of causing offense or disrupting preferred narratives. Biological sex is real. Borders and assimilation matter. Criminal behavior is not primarily a function of systemic racism. Academic standards measure something important. When a governing philosophy systematically subordinates these facts to ideological goals, the measurable results are declining competence, reduced safety, cultural fragmentation, and institutional distrust. That is the mechanism of decline.
Notes on the sources
The UK restriction on puberty blockers covers new prescriptions for gender dysphoria or incongruence in patients under 18, with exceptions for existing patients and clinical trials. The Cass Review found the evidence base for these treatments limited.
The House Homeland Security Committee’s 10.8 million figure covers FY2021 through FY2024 and includes encounters at ports of entry. CBP reports encounter events, which can include repeat encounters with the same person.
Pew’s 2013 survey found substantial variation across countries in support for making sharia official law. Its sample covered residents of the countries surveyed. Estimates for Muslim immigrants in Western Europe require separate surveys of those populations.
FBI releases put the larger single-year increase in murders between 2019 and 2020. The FBI estimated a further 4.3 percent increase from 2020 to 2021.
The Supreme Court’s 2023 decision in Students for Fair Admissions concerned the admissions programs at Harvard and the University of North Carolina. Applying the ruling’s reasoning to hiring is the author’s argument.
Documentation
Sources & documents
Public records, research, and reporting consulted for this opinion are linked below.
- Hormone treatments for children and young people: Clinical trial and consultationsHouse of Commons Library
- Cass review: how has report affected care for transgender young people?The Guardian
- U.K. Study Criticizes Puberty Blockers for Gender Dysphoria in MinorsThe Wall Street Journal
- Ban on puberty blockers to be made indefinite on experts’ adviceUK Department of Health and Social Care
- Nine key findings from the Cass report into gender transitionThe Times
- Gender medicine for children and young people is built on shaky foundationsThe BMJ
- Cass Review Finds Weak Evidence for Puberty Blockers, Hormones in Youth Gender CareMedPage Today
- Independent Review of Gender Identity Services for Children and Young People: Final ReportThe Cass Review / UK Government Web Archive
- Hormone treatments and age of consent: government policyHouse of Lords Library
- FY2024 border report: nationwide encounters since FY2021U.S. House Committee on Homeland Security
- What Do Recent Surveys of Muslim Immigrants in France, Germany and the U.K. Say About Views on Sharia and Civic Law?Factually
- The World’s Muslims: Religion, Politics and SocietyPew Research Center
- What role should religion play in Muslim- and Jewish-majority countries?Pew Research Center
- Muslims in Iraq, Afghanistan Most Likely to Want Sharia, Least Likely to Oppose Honor KillingsU.S. News & World Report
- How Sweden defied liberal outrage to crush the gang violence epidemicThe Telegraph
- Vulnerable area: Swedish police classificationWikipedia
- Fact check on claims about crime levels in SwedenReuters
- Facts about migration, integration and crime in SwedenGovernment Offices of Sweden
- How Sweden’s multicultural dream went fatally wrongThe Telegraph
- California sanctuary cities ignored nearly 9,000 ICE detainersNew York Post
- Which Sanctuary Jurisdictions Have Released the Most Criminals?Center for Immigration Studies
- New York City ICE detainers and federal enforcementU.S. Department of Homeland Security
- The Dangers of Illinois’s Sanctuary PoliciesU.S. House Judiciary Committee
- Sanctuary cities declined 17,864 requests to hold illegal immigrants for ICE in 2025: NoemDenver Gazette
- California: The Dangerous Consequences of Sanctuary Policies (interim staff report)U.S. House Judiciary Committee
- The Problem With Trump’s Crime ClaimsThe Atlantic
- Blue Cities Are Finally Showing Sanity on Drugs and CrimeCity Journal
- Violent crime trends across major U.S. cities in 2026Fox News
- The Blue City Murder ProblemThe Heritage Foundation
- FBI Releases 2020 Crime StatisticsFederal Bureau of Investigation
- FBI Releases 2021 Crime in the Nation StatisticsFederal Bureau of Investigation
- 2024 NAEP Grade 12 Reading: National Trends and Student SkillsThe Nation’s Report Card
- 2024 NAEP Grade 12 Mathematics ResultsThe Nation’s Report Card
- Student Test Scores Keep Falling. What’s Really to Blame?Education Next
- Good news in math, bad news in reading. What to know about the latest NAEP scoresNPR
- US student scores hit new lows in Nation’s Report CardUSA Today
- Reading, math continue slide in 2024 NAEP resultsK-12 Dive
- Nation’s report card: US children fall further behind in reading, make little improvement in mathCNN
- 10 Takeaways from the 2024 NAEP ResultsNational Assessment Governing Board
- The ‘Nation’s Report Card’ Is Out. Here’s What the Results Tell Us About America’s SchoolsManhattan Institute
- ‘These results are sobering’: US high school seniors’ reading and math scores plummetThe Guardian
- Colleges’ use of institutional neutrality and campus speechInside Higher Ed
- More than 1,000 US students punished over speech since 2020, report findsThe Guardian
- Compassionate EnforcementCity Journal
- Which US Cities Are Solving Homelessness?Independent Institute
- Homelessness Fell Again. Here’s WhyNext City
- Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard and UNC (Supreme Court opinion)Supreme Court of the United States
See a factual issue or a stronger primary source? Send it to No Left Turns on X. Material corrections will be noted on the article.